Welcome to the Most Educational Swimming Pool Blog in the Country!

Should I Fill In Or Replace My Inground Pool? A Few Thoughts To Consider

Posted by Jason Hughes


If you're reading this it's because you find yourself at a crossroads as to what to do with your existing inground pool.  We encounter folks all the time who purchased a pool decades earlier (perhaps when the children were small) but have reached a point where they are considering replacing or filling it in for one or more of the following reasons:

  • the older pool has become a maintenance burden 
  • it's difficult to justify maintenance/repair expenses based on how often the pool is used
  • the size and features of the pool no longer meet the needs of the pool owners  

Our aim today is to help you sort out what to do with your pool.  Let's start by looking at the pros and cons of filling in an existing pool vs opting for a complete replacement. 

Filling In An Existing Pool: Pros and Cons 


You can say goodbye to: 

  • Pool maintenance
  • Expense of buying chemicals and energy usage
  • Expense or burden of repairs


  • The expense to fill the pool in.  On average, it would cost about $3,000 to $5,000 in materials to fill the pool in, plus several thousand more in labor if you pay a contractor to do it for you.  

Pool Replacement: Pros and Cons

Since we began in 2001, we have replaced approximately thirty existing inground concrete or vinyl liner pools with new fiberglass pools.  

Here are some of the reasons why our customers chose to do so: 

  • Fiberglass pools are much easier to maintain 
  • Fiberglass pools use less chemicals
  • Fiberglass pools have the lowest lifetime cost of ownership
  • Fiberglass pools have features such as steps, benches, tanning ledges, etc integrated into the pool shell.  This is a huge advantage for those who previously owned a typical vinyl liner pool.  
  • Fiberglass pools are extremely attractive 
  • Fiberglass pools are incredibly durable


  • A typical pool replacement costs between $45,000 and $65,000

If you're still on the fence, perhaps you should check out the following video that showcases the replacement of a vinyl liner pool with a fiberglass pool.  

We hope this has helped you decide what to do with your inground pool.  If you'd like to learn more about how fiberglass, vinyl liner, and concrete pools compare, click here.

If you'd like to receive a quote to replace your pool with one of our inground fiberglass pool designs click here. 

If you have any questions or comments about filling in an existing pool or replacing it with a new one, please leave them below.

Thanks and happy swimming!

Download Our Valuable and Informational E-book detailing how to buy an inground pool in 2016

Leave A Comment!